While Shedeur Sanders may be the Cleveland Browns' starter for the remainder of the 2025 regular season, what they decide to in 2026 is another question. The former Colorado star is 1-3 in his first four NFL starts but has shown flashes of playmaking ability in that time and has given the Browns

Allen, whom the Browns passed on at No. 1 overall in 2018 in favor of Baker Mayfield, is No. 4 in the NFL with a 104.3 rating, and No. 2 with a 70.0 completion percentage. Contrast that with Browns rookie Shedeur Sanders, who’s 46th with a 68.1 rating, and 48th with a 52.2 completion percentage as he heads into his fifth NFL start.